Best Shaving Cream For Safety Razor

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

A double-edged razor has many benefits that will motivate you to make this product your first choice. First, it offers the closest possible shave because it can reach all the way down the grain.

A double-edged razor can reduce, if not entirely prevent razor burns giving you the fresh shave you desire.

These razors are economically sound since they last longer. A single blade can give you a close shave for a week to 10 days. The double-edged razors are offered in a box of 100. So you are set up for a while.

There is also the environmental factor that makes these razors win out. These durable safety razors offer a consistent shave.

We went beyond the aisle of the supermarket to find you top picks of highly rated and high-quality shaving creams that pair perfectly with your safety razor.

Read Related Article: Best Double Edge Razor Blades for Sensitive Skin

Our Best Shaving Cream for Safety Razor Reviews and Comparisons

Comparison Chart

41uts9z9qPL. SL500
Cremo Barber Grade Original Shave Cream, Astonishingly Superior Ultra-Slick Shaving Cream Fights Nicks, Cuts and Razor Burn, 6 Fl Oz (2 Pack)
61DVgvnLdkL. SL500
Shaving Cream for Men with Sandalwood Essential Oil – Thick Lather for Traditional and Cartridge Shaving – by Rocky Mountain Barber Company – 5oz Tin
RICH ANTI AGING SHAVING CREAM FOR MEN – Shavology Shave Lather infused with Golden Seaweed For Men – Advanced Shaving Cream 2-in-1 Anti-Aging Skin Care Eliminates Razor Burn, Bumps, Rashes and Ingrown
41rxPyJ NYL. SL500
Premium and Hydrating Shaving Gel, Shave Lube by Wild Willies – Formulated with Caffeine, Calming Jojoba Oil & Cooling Eucalyptus Oil to Reduce Redness, Fight Nicks, Cuts, and Razor Burns

1. Cremo Original Shave Cream

41uts9z9qPL. SL500

Product Highlights

Cremo Original Shave Cream is made from a specially manufactured formula that makes the molecules super slick, which makes it an easy shaving experience with your razor. With lots of natural goodness and paraben-free, it is kind to your skin.

Its high concentration means that you only need to use a very little bit at a time, making it economically friendly as well.


This product’s active ingredients include macadamia seed oil, aloe, calendula, lemon, papaya, and olive leaf extracts.

What We Like About Cremo Original Shave Cream

Packed with lots of natural ingredients that will benefit your skin.

What We Don’t Like About Cremo Original Shave Cream

It contains chemicals that may irritate sensitive skin. You may want to test it out if you have sensitive skin before investing a lot of money in this product.


  • Made with the best, natural ingredients
  • Paraben free
  • Not tested on animals


  • Not suited for sensitive skin
  • Not enough coating and protection

2. Shaving Cream for Men by Rocky Mountain Barber Company

61DVgvnLdkL. SL500

Product Highlights

Rocky Mountain Barber Company makes their men’s shaving cream in small batches. This means that all the natural goodness, refreshing smell, and all its signature qualities, are preserved to their highest potential.


It uses almost all-natural ingredients, including coconut oil, grapeseed oil, argan oil, jojoba oil & sandalwood oil.

What We Like About Shaving Cream for Men by Rocky Mountain Barber Company

It is great for almost all skin types. The light oils used to mean that it won’t be too heavy for oily skin, and yet hydrating enough for dry skin, with or without a brush.

The added menthol will give you a kick in the morning.

What We Don’t Like About Shaving Cream for Men by Rocky Mountain Barber Company

If you want a quick shave, this product is not for you. You need a little preparation time before you begin to shave. Not everyone wants the menthol as it overpowers the sandalwood.


  • Softer face after use
  • A little goes a long way
  • Top of the can is gnarled which makes it easier to open


  • Does not lather.
  • Scent wears off halfway through the day

3. Shavology Shave Lather

Product Highlights

Shaveology Shave Lather is one of the tops of the line anti-aging products on the market. You may not be feeling the effects of aging, but this anti-aging product is as luxurious as a warm straight razor shave.It was developed to be gentle enough for sensitive skin, and aggressive enough for face, neck, and head.

Any anti-aging product worth its salt is filled with the most hydrating and restorative properties, but this one goes a step ahead integrating golden seaweed into its already tasty ingredients list.


This product contains the finest ingredients to nourish the skin during and after the shaving process. Golden Seaweed is added to the formula to include the benefits of anti-aging.

The skin is hydrated and protected all day from free radicals that are known to negatively impact the skin.

What We Like About Shavology Shave Lather

This product softens the beard and creates a barrier that ensures your razor glides smoothly over the skin, offering a close and comfortable shave with every use.

Razor burns and ingrown hairs are effectively prevented.

What We Don’t Like About Shavology Shave Lather

There is not enough lubrication which means the skin is not properly hydrated. Some find the scent overwhelming. It does not lather easily.


  • Rich foam lather
  • Anti-aging formula added
  • A 7 oz bottle lasts for 120 days


  • Price may be reasonable but the quality is subpar
  • Product comes out dry

4. Wild Willies Shave Lube Premium Shaving Gel with Jojoba & Eucalyptus

41rxPyJ NYL. SL500

Product Highlights

If you are looking for a morning routine to get you out of the house feeling ready for the day inside and out, this is for you. The Wild Willies Shave Lube Premium Shaving Gel is part of a four product routine that uses caffeine to give you that boost, peppermint for the fresh smell, and packs a punch of oils, keeping your beard and skin maintained all day.

Of course, you can also use this product as a stand-alone for your beard, but your face is the canvas for your beard, and that skin needs care, too. Just something to think about.


The benefits of antioxidant-rich, naturally-derived caffeine will reduce any redness that occurs during shaving. The calming properties of Jojoba and Eucalyptus will keep your skin looking and feeling fresh and healthy all day long.

What We Like About Wild Willies Shave Lube Premium Shaving Gel with Jojoba & Eucalyptus

Very natural and pleasantly scented. Nonsticky texture. Invigorating, nourishing and natural, this product really has it all.

What We Don’t Like About Wild Willies Shave Lube Premium Shaving Gel with Jojoba & Eucalyptus

The men may not have enough product with each order, as their wives are using this product as well


  • Environmentally friendly
  • Lubricates adequately for shaving
  • Eliminates any redness from shaving


  • None to highligh


How Can I Prepare My Skin For A Great Shave?

  • Shower Your skin is more supple and pores more open after taking a steaming hot shower. This leaves with less resistant hair to shave.
  • Exfoliating is a process to remove all the excess dead skin cells. When you take the time for this process then you offer your skin the chance to breathe and prevent breakouts and skin irritation.
  • Skincare routine is necessary to keep your skin healthy. If you have sensitive skin it is likely to be a result of overstimulation or under stimulation of a particular pH makeup. When your skincare is part of your routine then you create an optimal environment for your skin and shaving becomes a smoother process.